grashupfer (grashupfer) wrote,
grashupfer
grashupfer

More on Stalker

The joke: In the early scene with the convertible and the mysterious woman not allowed to visit the Zone, Writer says, among other throwaway lines, [in the English subtitles], "To live in the Middle Ages was interesting." If this was Pynchon [the Zone?], we might think this entire scene was a set up for this joke. People probably recognize that actor. Is he saying he'd have preferred life in Tarkovsky's other movie, Andrei Rublev? Well, he probably would have. He *was* Andrei Rublev.

More spoilerish.

Doubt: This is the feeling in my own stomach as I watch Stalker. Doubt that anything sacred actually exists in the Zone - which looks ordinary and real. Then belief. Doubt that the dangers Stalker warns of exist. Then belief. Doubt about Stalker's ridiculous method of finding the way. Then belief in it. Doubt that Stalkers can't enter the room, doubt that Stalker himself hasn't, can't, wouldn't. But this is the doubt of Professor and Writer. Stalker inverts the typical mystery religion when he says that only those without hope can approach or arrive at The Room. Doubt about that. Then belief.

This is so different from Prometheus in which the scientists are competent and confident and never doubt as they seek their own version of the sacred. They got straight at it and find it with ease and swiftness. This is a very different way of telling the same story.
Tags: 1001 movies, stalker
Subscribe

  • (no subject)

    A run of fun re-watches. #871 - Knife in the Water (1962) So efficient even in his first feature. There is nothing wasted. It's a bracing example…

  • (no subject)

    I can’t believe how good Roadside Picnic is. Sad like Hemingway’s good stories and a voice like Chandler but also totally weird. This is the book…

  • (no subject)

    The Dougie stuff sure is some uninspired stuff. Episode 5 is not a very good gear shift. I'm not encouraged.

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 4 comments